The 'expert' in problem-based and case-based learning: necessary or not?

Full Abstract

BACKGROUND: Problem-based learning (PBL) and other small-group teaching methods which incorporate principles of adult learning, are exciting innovations in medical education. In the application of these methods to medical curricula many schools have introduced non-expert tutors. However, research evaluating the effectiveness of non-expert lead teaching has been inconclusive. AIM: The present study aim was to compare the outcome of teaching in small groups facilitated by either an 'expert' or a 'non-expert' tutor, in a single topic area. METHOD: Fourth-year medical students were allocated randomly to teaching of eating disorders either by a non-expert or an expert tutor. Outcomes were evaluated by (i) a knowledge test, and (ii) self-report ratings by tutors and students of their learning methods and other qualities. RESULTS: The study found that while the non-expert tutor was rated more highly for her group management skills, and she also rated her students more highly in the area of oral communication, students who were taught by the expert scored higher in the end-of-course test in the topic area. CONCLUSION: The findings suggest that caution should be exercised, and the need for more research before widespread adoption of teaching by non-expert tutors.

Author information

Author/s: Hay, P J (PJ); Katsikitis, M (M);

Affiliation: Department of Psychiatry, University of Adelaide, Adelaide, Australia.

Journal and publication information

Publication Type: Clinical Trial; Journal Article; Randomized Controlled Trial

Journal: Medical education (Med Educ), published in ENGLAND. (Language: eng)

Reference: 2001-Jan; vol 35 (issue 1) : pp 22-6

Dates: Created 2001/01/31; Completed 2001/03/01; Revised 2004/11/17;

PMID: 11123591, status: MEDLINE (last retrieval date: 2/18/2009, IMS Date: )

Sourced from the National Library of Medicine. Abstract text and other information may be subject to copyright.

External Links for this article
(including full text providers, if available):

Click Electronic Full-text Provider Links to see options for finding the electronic full text links to this article. Note there may be a subscription or fee required for access to the full text. See our FAQ for information on finding FREE full text articles.

This article may also be located in paper journal collections available in many libraries. Use the Journal and Publication Information above to find the full article.